1nTest · strategy backtester and trading bot builder

Is Smart Money Concepts profitable? 5 strategies, 7,450 trades after costs

We backtested 5 common Smart Money strategies on 100 strategy-and-asset pairs in 2022–2025. After commission, spread and swap, 1 of 5 strategies had a positive result per trade; across all 7,450 trades the average was −0.14 R, and 34 of 100 pairs ended in profit.

What we tested

Five strategies built from the concepts most SMC courses teach: a fair value gap, an order block, a sweep of an opening level, a range deviation and the Asian session range. Each strategy kept the same rules on every asset; nothing was tuned per asset.

The result by strategy

Fair value gap after a sweep
Trades301
Win rate26.6%
Before commission and swap+0.06 R
After all costs−0.00 R
Assets in profit11 of 20
Order block and break of structure
Trades697
Win rate23.1%
Before commission and swap−0.08 R
After all costs−0.12 R
Assets in profit6 of 20
Sweep of an opening level
Trades5,724
Win rate22.1%
Before commission and swap−0.12 R
After all costs−0.17 R
Assets in profit4 of 20
Range deviation
Trades168
Win rate21.8%
Before commission and swap+0.15 R
After all costs+0.11 R
Assets in profit6 of 20
Asian session range
Trades560
Win rate39.7%
Before commission and swap+0.02 R
After all costs−0.02 R
Assets in profit7 of 20

Results are in R, the amount risked per trade. The spread is already inside every price because entries and exits fill at bid and ask; commission and swap together took 0.04 R per trade on average. For the fair value gap and the Asian range that difference is the whole story: positive before commission and swap, negative after.

How to read this

  • A concept is not a strategy. The same order block can be traded with many entries, stops and targets; this test measures one honest version of each, not every possible one.
  • A win rate means nothing without the target. The Asian range wins often because its target is near; the order block wins rarely because its target is three times the stop.
  • Some assets show a profit for every strategy. Picking them after the fact is selection, not an edge; check them on a period you did not use to choose them.

What would change the answer

A filter that holds on new data, a cheaper broker or a longer stop that costs less in R. Each of these is measurable: test it on many assets, on a period kept aside, and compare it with a random filter of the same size.

How we measured

  • Engine backtest on the production server, each strategy on each asset separately, period 2022-01-01 to 2026-01-01, starting balance $10,000, fixed risk of 1% per trade.
  • Commission and swap measured for one commission-charging broker; entries and exits at bid and ask prices.
  • Win rate = take-profits ÷ (take-profits + stop-losses). A pair is in profit when its net result over all trades is above zero.

Backtests run on October 25, 2026.

Questions

Does Smart Money Concepts trading work?

In this test of common SMC strategies on many assets, 1 of 5 had a positive result per trade after trading costs. Each strategy was profitable on some assets and lost money on others.

Why do SMC backtests on video look better?

They usually show one asset, a short period and no commission or swap. This test used every asset, four years and full costs.

For education, not investment advice. Past results, including backtests, do not guarantee future results.

← All articles