What a trade really costs: commission, spread and swap as a share of the risk
Across 7,450 engine-backtested trades on 20 assets, the median trade paid 0.09 R in costs: commission, swap and the spread at the moment of entry, as a share of the amount risked. The tighter the stop, the higher the share: 0.12 R with stops on the five-minute chart and 0.05 R with stops on the four-hour chart.
Why measure costs in R
A strategy wins and loses in units of risk. Commission per lot is the same whether the stop is ten pips or a hundred, but as a share of the risk it is ten times larger with the tight stop. The spread works the same way. So the useful question is not how many dollars a trade costs but what share of R it costs, because that is what the strategy has to earn back on every trade.
Cost by stop timeframe
| Strategy template | Stop timeframe | Median cost per trade |
|---|---|---|
| Asian session range | M5 | 0.12 R |
| Order block + break of structure | M15 | 0.09 R |
| Level raid + break of structure | M15 | 0.09 R |
| Range deviation | H1 | 0.05 R |
| Fair value gap + liquidity sweep | H4 | 0.05 R |
Of the median cost, the spread at entry makes up 0.05 R and the commission 0.02 R; swap matters only for positions held overnight. 19% of all trades paid more than a fifth of their risk in costs.
Cost by asset
The same rules on different assets cost very different amounts. The most expensive asset in the set, XAGUSD, paid a median of 0.33 R per trade; the cheapest, BTCUSD, paid 0.03 R. That is a 9.9× difference before the strategy has done anything.
What it means for a strategy
- Compare the cost in R with the average result per trade before costs. A setup that earns a tenth of R per trade before costs and pays a tenth in costs earns nothing.
- A lower timeframe gives more trades but a larger cost per trade. Moving the stop to a higher timeframe often helps more than adding a filter.
- Asset selection is part of the strategy: dropping the assets where the cost per trade is highest can change the sign of the result.
How we measured
- Five strategy templates on twenty assets, engine backtests on the production server, period 2022-01-01 to 2026-01-01, fixed risk of 1% per trade.
- Cost in R per trade = (commission + swap) ÷ amount risked + spread at entry ÷ stop distance. Both parts are fields of each engine trade.
- Commission and swap are measured for one commission-charging broker; spreads by hour of the broker's server clock. Entries and exits use bid and ask prices.
- Median rather than average, because a few trades with very tight stops have very large costs.
Backtests run on October 24, 2026.
Questions
Is the spread counted twice?
No. With bid and ask prices the spread is paid inside the entry and exit prices. Here it is shown separately only to measure how much of the stop it takes up.
Can I check the cost of my own trade?
Yes, the trade cost calculator uses the same measured commission, spreads and swaps.
For education, not investment advice. Past results, including backtests, do not guarantee future results.
← All research