FX Replay alternative: automated backtests instead of manual replay
FX Replay is a manual replay simulator: you click through the chart and place every trade yourself. 1nTest is the automated alternative: you describe the rules once and the engine finds every setup on several assets with real costs. Our grid of 100 such backtests produced 7,450 trades, a volume no one replays by hand.
Two different ways to test
FX Replay recreates live trading on history: the chart moves bar by bar, you decide, you place the order, the platform keeps the journal. It trains execution and lets you test ideas that are hard to formalise. Its limits are the limits of manual work: the number of trades you have the time to take, and the temptation to skip the setups you do not like.
1nTest does the opposite. The rules are built from blocks, such as a fair value gap, an order block, a sweep or a break of structure on chosen timeframes, and the engine applies them to every bar of the history on several assets at once. Every setup that matches is traded, including the ones that look ugly.
Side by side
| FX Replay | 1nTest | |
|---|---|---|
| How a test runs | manual, bar by bar | automatic, by your rules |
| Coding | not needed | not needed |
| Free plan | yes: two sessions, fifty trades per session | free during the beta |
| Paid plans (checked 2026-11-15) | $17.99 and $35 per month | prices announced before the public launch |
| Trading costs in the result | you account for them yourself | commission, spread at bid and ask, swap |
| Several assets in one test | one chart at a time | yes |
| Checks against luck | Monte Carlo on paid plans | out-of-sample and random-chance checks |
| From test to live trading | no | the same rules run as a bot on MT5 |
Why the number of trades matters
A result based on a few dozen trades is mostly noise. Our five strategy templates on separate assets produced 7,450 trades over four years. The median cost of a trade was 0.09 R, and after costs only 34 of 100 strategy and asset pairs ended in profit. Numbers like these need hundreds of trades per idea, which is where automation pays off.
Who should choose which
- Choose FX Replay if you want to practise decision-making and execution, or your strategy depends on discretion that cannot be written as rules.
- Choose 1nTest if your strategy can be written as rules and you want to know how it does over years, on many assets, after costs, and then run it as a bot.
- Many traders use both: manual replay to develop the feel for a setup, an automated backtest to check whether it pays.
How we measured
- FX Replay plans and limits as listed on fxreplay.com/pricing on 2026-11-15; prices and limits change, check them there.
- Our figures: grid backtests of five strategy templates, each asset separately, 2022-01-01 to 2026-01-01, net of commission, spread at bid and ask, and swap.
Backtests run on October 30, 2026.
Questions
Is there a free FX Replay alternative?
1nTest is free during its beta. FX Replay itself has a free plan with two sessions and up to fifty trades per session.
Can 1nTest replay the chart bar by bar like FX Replay?
No. 1nTest runs rules automatically; it shows every trade on the chart afterwards, but it is not a manual trading simulator.
Is manual backtesting worse than automated?
It answers a different question: how you trade a setup, rather than how the setup performs over hundreds of trades with costs.
For education, not investment advice. Past results, including backtests, do not guarantee future results.
← All articles